...and it's clear that I need new clothes.
As expected, my wardrobe didn't fare well in the clothes survey we posted
a few weeks back. But that's OK. I thought it was time for an upgrade, and your comments only affirmed that for me. Comments like "boring and basic" and "if you think a 12-year-old boy might own the same shirt, you should ditch it" really put things in perspective.
Here's a summary of what the 38 people who took the survey said:

Shirt #1: Keep it! (57%)
Shirt #2: Keep it! (61%)
Shirt #3: Ditch it! (64%)
Shirt #4: Ditch it! (51%)
Shirt #5: Ditch it! (63%)
Comments for shirts 1-5: Several people suggested that I "maybe find some shirts that are slightly more fitted." One person noted that they weren't suggesting that I "have to gay out, necessarily," but "clothes that fit a little closer to your body are a good thing." Another person berated the plainly colored shirts. "Is there anything more boring and basic?" OK. So smaller sizes are good and a little flavor wouldn't kill me.
Verdict for shirts 1-5: I'll keep shirts 1 and 2 for weekend wear, but ditch the rest.

Shirt #6: Keep it! (71%)
Shirt #7: Ditch it! (56%)
Shirt #8: Ditch it! (53%)
Shirt #9: Ditch it! (55%)
Shirt #10: Ditch it! (70%)
Comments for shirts 1-6: The best advice here was succinct: "If you think a 12-year-old boy might own the same shirt, you should ditch it." Duly noted. Also, some unsolicited advice on my denim shorts -- never wear unless "at an outdoor summer concert, participating in an athletic event, vacationing in Bermuda or named Mark Whalberg" -- was helpful since I knew I had to buy new shorts.
Verdict for shirts 6-10: I'll keep shirt 6, which scored surprisingly well, and ditch the rest.

Shirt #11: Ditch it! (81%)
Shirt #12: Ditch it! (61%)
Shirt #13: Ditch it! (55%)
Shirt #14: Ditch it! (52%)
Shirt #15: Ditch it! (71%)
Comments for shirts 11-15: There was absolutely no love for the mock turtlenecks. "The mock turtleneck doesn’t really suit you," said one. "The mock turtleneck went out with Ducky just before he was ditched at the dance by his best friend for a richer, more handsome guy."
Verdict for shirts 11-15: Since I don't want to be ditched by Annie for a more handsome guy, all five shirts have been discarded.

Shirt #16: Keep it! (77%)
Shirt #17: Keep it! (77%)
Shirt #18: Keep it! (58%)
Shirt #19: Keep it! (78%)
Shirt #20: Keep it! (52%)
Comments for shirts 16-20: Reactions to these shirts were mixed, but generally favorable. There was much praise for the Nintendo hoodie -- "cute, retro, and red is a good color on you" -- and the black shirt. The striped shirt, though, was alternately described as "awesome" and making me "look like a convict or a heroin junkie."
Verdict for shirts 16-20: I'm keeping all five, but I'll be careful in my presentation of the striped shirt.

Shirt #21: Keep it! (69%)
Shirt #22: Ditch it! (54%)
Shirt #23: Keep it! (85%)
Shirt #24: Keep it! (54%)
Shirt #25: Keep it! (64%)
Pants (#21-23): Ditch them! (58%)
Pants (#24-25): Keep it! (71%)
Comments for shirts and pants 21-25: Although there were few comments specific to the most supported items, shirts 21 and 23, the numbers speak for themselves. Most comments were directed toward the pants. There was much love for the brown pair, but little for the khaki.
Verdict for shirts and pants 21-25: I'm following all suggested outcomes here except for ditching the khaki pants. Knowing that there are more fashionable options, though, I'll keep my eyes open.

Shirt #26: Ditch it! (89%)
Shirt #27: Keep it! (65%)
Shirt #28: Ditch it! (63%)
Pants (#26-28): Ditch them! (62%)
Comments for shirts and pants 26-28: There wasn't a lot of love here. Comments noted "there is nothing flattering" about shirt 26, that shirt 27 "makes me think of Jerry Seinfeld’s poofy shirt," and shirt 28 is "bad bad bad bad bad!" And the pants? "Pleats. No. Bad Josh."
Verdict for shirts and pants 26-28: I'm ditching shirt 26 and keeping shirt 27. I'm going against the grain on shirt 28, since it's been well received in person, and the pants, but only on the latter until I find a replacement.

Tie #1: Keep it! (60%)
Tie #2: Keep it! (64%)
Tie #3: Keep it! (52%)
Tie #4: Ditch it! (92%)
Tie #5: Ditch it! (88%)
Tie #6: Keep it! (62%)
Tie #7: Keep it! (71%)
Tie #8: Keep it! (77%)
Tie #9: Ditch it! (52%)
Tie #10: Ditch it! (58%)
Comments and verdict for ties 1-10: Opinions were mixed on many of the ties, but it was abundantly clear that ties 4 and 5 had to go. So gone they are. Ties 9 and 10 also -- surprisingly -- are ejected from the collection. And here I thought they looked nice. Shows what I know.
So there you have it. Armed with this knowledge, I'll expand my wardrobe and try to make myself a bit more fashionable. And thank you again to all who participated! I really appreciate your honesty and input!